Arrow Queen
Arrow Queen, located at 429 N Main St, New Carlisle, OH 45344, offers a charming and satisfying dining experience that combines classic American comfort food with a friendly, welcoming atmosphere. This local favorite serves up a range of delicious options, from tasty hot dogs and burgers to indulgent hand-dipped ice cream and shakes, making it a go-to spot for both casual bites and sweet treats.
An All-American Menu with Something for Everyone
The menu at Arrow Queen is a true reflection of all things American comfort food, featuring a variety of hot dogs that cater to every preference. Among the standout options are the Arrow Dog, Coney Dog, and the unique Cincinnati Dog. For a local twist, try the New Carlisle Dog, or go classic with the Chicago Dog. These mouthwatering hot dogs are the perfect balance of flavor and simplicity, paired wonderfully with some of the restaurant's standout sides.
If you're craving a bit more than just a dog, Arrow Queen offers a variety of sandwiches, including the Cheeseburger, Bacon Cheeseburger, and Texas Tenderloin. The Double Cheeseburger and Bacon Double Cheeseburger are also great choices for those with a hearty appetite. For something lighter, their fresh salads, like the Taco Salad and Chicken Salad, offer a refreshing contrast to the heavier options.
For side dishes, you can enjoy classic Fries or Tots, with options to make them extra indulgent by adding cheese or chili. Fried mushrooms, onion chips, and chili cheese fries are other crowd favorites, offering a perfect combination of crunch and flavor. And don't forget to pair your meal with a cold soft drink or a creamy shake or malt. The Cyclones, such as Reese Cup and Butterfinger, are particularly tempting for anyone with a sweet tooth.
Sweet Treats and Hand-Dipped Ice Cream
One of the highlights of dining at Arrow Queen is their wide selection of hand-dipped ice cream. From the classic Banana Split to fun options like Kiddie Cones and a Quart of Hand Dipped for sharing, there's something for every ice cream lover. If you're in the mood for something a bit more adventurous, try the Ice Cream Nachos or a Foot Long Banana Split, both perfect for satisfying your cravings with a fun twist.
For those who enjoy more traditional sweets, the Shakes & Malts come in a variety of flavors, including Smoothies and Floats, while the Cotton Candy and Cookies-N-Cream offer a nostalgic taste of childhood.
A Friendly and Welcoming Atmosphere
Arrow Queen is not just about the food—it's also about the experience. The restaurant’s atmosphere is perfect for a laid-back meal with friends or family. The on-site parking makes it convenient for customers, and the restaurant also takes reservations, ensuring a smooth dining experience. Guests can even enjoy a bit of outdoor seating under the new awning, a great feature for those looking for a pleasant break during a bike ride.
Customer Reviews Reflect Consistency and Quality
Arrow Queen has earned a reputation for providing great food and service. Customers like Courtney M. have praised the ice cream and the friendly service, despite a minor delay due to the restaurant learning a new computer system. For others like Mick W., the entire menu is a hit, with the recommendation to call ahead for faster service—a great tip for those looking to skip the line. Emma H. had a great experience last summer, enjoying both shakes and fries, and mentioned the “amazing prices” and “great food,” ensuring a return visit in the future.
These reviews highlight Arrow Queen’s commitment to both quality food and excellent customer service. It’s clear that Arrow Queen has built a loyal following by consistently delivering delicious meals in a friendly and welcoming environment.
Whether you're craving a classic hot dog, a juicy burger, or a sweet ice cream treat, Arrow Queen offers a delightful array of options that cater to all tastes. With excellent service, a cozy atmosphere, and a menu full of American favorites, it’s easy to see why this local gem continues to attract visitors from near and far.
Reviews
Everything on their menu is good! Call ahead your order for faster service or wait outside and talk to friends in line.
Stopped here last summer for a shake and fries with a friend. Amazing prices and great food. Will 100% be coming back!
After the disappointment of finding Wot-A-Dog is closed on Mondays (& Tuesdays), we decided to make our first visit to Arrow Queen. Well-being , it won't be our last visit. Everything was delicious! First off, we tried the Footlong Cincinnati Dog with yummy coney sauce, nicely chopped onions (I value those), and cheese. We both thought this was the tastiest item we ordered. It had everything a good coney dog requires. Next up was the Footlong Arrow Dog - a hot dog topped with a pepperoni pizza. It was fun to try a different creation. It turned out to be OK, but needed something more. Maybe those delicious onions? We also tried a cheeseburger with lettuce, tomato, and onion. It was good, bug with the Cincinnati dog on the menu, we probably would just stick with the dog going forward. The small twist cone was plenty of ice cream and a very fresh cone. The dog even got in on the act with a dog sundae. It had the teeniest milk bone biscuit I've ever seen. It was so adorable. There was plenty of ice cream for our old pup. To drink we had some tasty Dad's root beer. You gotta have root beer when you're inhaling a fantastic coney, but a diet option would have been nice. Overall, this was a good alternative when Wot-A -Dog is closed or anytime really. It's just nothing beats a frosty mug of root beer.
Stopped in and grabbed some ice cream. The cyclone was recommended and it's fantastic.
The food is good the ice cream and service are great. They're learning a new computer system so expect a long wait. They have a new awning for about 3 tables which is a nice sun break after a bike ride.